home about us aeration theory products & systems what's new case histories literature contact us
applications wastewater treatment aquaculture lake and harbor restoration golf courses recreational / decorative reps
 
 
Links:
 
Back to Products
 
How It Works
 
Applications
 
Specifications
 
Sizing Tools
 
Competition
 
FAQ's
 
Site Photos
 
Case Histories
 
What's New!
 
Inquiry to AIII
 
Español

 




Competition of the Aire-O2® Series II Aspirator Aerator
See the benefits of the Series II when compared head-to-head
with other aerators in the marketplace today


  • Paddlewheel Aerators

  • Submersible Aeratiors

  • Asian Imitation Aspirator Aerators


    Paddlewheel Aerators

    Compare the benefits between Series II and Asian made Paddlewheel Aerators

    AIRE-O2® Series II Aspirator Aerator
    Asian Made Paddlewheel Aerator
    • Circulates oxygen rich surface water by destratifying pond water column. This ensures uniform pond temperature and oxygen levels throughout the pond.
    • Heavy splashing on the top layer of the pond leads to unequal temperature and DO in pond bottom (see photos above). Unable to mix depths greater than 1m.
    • Water lubricated bearing requires no additional lubrication or maintenance.
    • Many moving parts and questionable workmanship leads to high maintenance and repair costs.
    • One moving part; only 10 parts in total.
    • Many moving parts; more than 30 parts total.
    • No gearbox design; thus no lubrication or frequent failures will occur.
    • Gearbox design requires constant lubrication and frequent replacement.
    • Lightweight, can be moved from pond to pond by only one person.
    • Bulky and heavy, may take up to four people to move from pond.
    • Aeration is done below surface; does not cause changes in temperature or salinity.
    • Heavy splashing leads to higher salinity levels due to increased evaporation rates.
    • Hi-tech composition materials with corrosion free elements. Materials for Series II aerator used in aerospace and automotive industry.
    • Many parts are made of galvanized steel, aluminum and low grade stainless steel - all of which corrode quickly in pond environment.
    • Able to adjust angle for shallow or deep ponds.
    • Only able to aerate shallow ponds.
    • Viewed by industry as a farm investment.
    • Viewed by industry as pond consumable
    • Operates level with fluctuating water levels
    • Must be leveled periodically or amperage draw increases.
    • Precision engineered to stay afloat in all weather conditions.
    • May tip over on windy days.
    • Standard 1 year warranty; strong customer service and field service departments.
    • Warranties are suspects; little customer service
    • Made in USA, quality craftsmanship
    • Of questionable quality and workmanship.

    Top of Page
    Submersible Aerators

    Compare the benefits between Series II and Submersible Aerators

    Aire-O2® Series II Aspirator Aerator
    Submersible Aerators
    • EPA defined ‘fine bubbles’ allow for maximum oxygen dispersion and oxygen transfer throughout pond
    • Aerator emits large bubbles which float immediately to the surface (see photos above).
    • Surface mounted motor ensures no contact with corrosive water in pond.
    • Submersible motors suspect to failure and leakage, especially if cycled off and on daily.
    • Able to mix fine bubbles deep below the surface throughout the entire pond in one unit.
    • Due to submersible design, additional stationary mixers are often necessary for assistance in mixing.
    • Available in multiple sizes (1 – 7.5Hp)
    • Largest sized aerator is 2.2 Hp
    • Hi-tech propeller design ensures smooth operation.
    • Heavy cavitations occur on propeller during operation
    • One year warranty on equipment
    • Suspect warranty policy and long parts delays
    • Actual operating power is 90-95% of motor name plate; thus giving the farming what they are paying for and need for their application
    • Actual operating power is 67-80% of motor name plate; thus deceiving customer from what they are actually purchasing and require for their application
    • Hi-tech composition materials with corrosion free elements. Materials for Series II aerator used in aerospace and automotive industry.
    • Made of cheap plastics very susceptible to breakage and short lifetimes.
    • No efficiency loss due to simple direct drive hollow shaft aspirator design.
    • Tremendous loss of efficiency due to power wasted from sucking air above waters surface down to the submersible motor.
    • Able to mix all sizes / depths of ponds due to multiple angle design and large scope of equipment (1-7.5 Hp). Small sized fine bubbles allow for maximum dispersion.
    • Unable to mix deep waters as the deeper you lower the motor, the less efficient the aerator performs. Also, large bubble immediately escape to water surface.
    • Numerous independent tests worldwide; proven and trusted to the industry for over 30 years!
    • Lack of independent testing; relatively short history

    Top of Page
    Asian Imitation Aspirator Aerators

    Compare the benefits between Series II and Asian Imitation aspirator

    AIRE-O2® Series II Aerator
    Asian Imitation Aerators
    • Specially Designed Propeller For Aeration
    • Use Cheap Off the Shelf Marine or Boat Propeller
    • EPA defined ‘fine bubbles’ allow for maximum oxygen dispersion and oxygen transfer throughout the entire pond
    • Aerator emits large bubbles which rise immediately to the surface (see photo above)
    • Experts in aspirator aerators to the aquaculture industry; we only work with the best!
    • Companies peddle many different types of aerators to the Industry; not focused on selling quality
    • Engineered Propeller Means Smooth Operation and Low Maintenance
    • Propellers Causes Cavitation, Vortexing and Vibration Leading to Shorten Aerator Lifetime
    • Due to Design, Much Higher Oxygen Transfer and Mixing
    • Very Poor Oxygen Transfer and Mixing
    • 378 m3 test pool facilities and R&D Center
    • Questionable testing facilities and product expertise
    • Multiple Aerator Sizes (1-7.5Hp) for aquaculture and wastewater treatment (up to 150 Hp)
    • Only Have 1 and 2 Hp sizes
    • Numerous independent tests worldwide; proven and trusted to the industry for over 30 years!
    • Lack of independent testing; relatively short history
    • Pioneers of the Aspirator Technology with over 30 years of experience!
    • Made From A Company Who Are Not Aeration Experts

    Top of Page